Articles
Oct 30, 2023

M&A Factors in Negotiating Executive Employment Agreements

M&A Factors in Negotiating Executive Employment Agreements

M&A Factors in Negotiating Executive Employment Agreements

Mergers and acquisitions (M&A) can be an exciting yet challenging time for executives. Amidst the whirlwind of deal-making, it’s easy to overlook the importance of carefully negotiating an executive employment agreement. But did you know that a well-crafted employment agreement can safeguard your interests and even enhance your career prospects? In this article, we’ll explore the complexities of employment agreements as they relate to M&A, offering insights and strategies for navigating these critical negotiations successfully.

Short Summary

  • Navigate M&A in Executive Employment Agreements with consideration to severance terms, remuneration, bonus and stock options.
  • Change-in-control provisions protect the executive’s job security during a merger or acquisition.
  • Leverage knowledge of leverage points and collaborate with legal counsel for successful negotiations. Remain flexible and adaptable.

Navigating Mergers and Acquisitions in an Executive Employment Agreement

An executive employment agreement can be intricate and multifaceted, particularly for the chief executive officer. These agreements typically involve various provisions to protect both the company and the executive, covering aspects such as compensation, stock options, severance terms, and other remuneration.

Executives often receive bonuses, restricted stock, and restricted stock units as part of their compensation packages, in accordance with company policies and regulations. Lower management employees may also be granted stock options, subject to internal revenue code and other applicable rules.

Change-in-Control Provisions and Golden Parachute Clauses

Change-in-control provisions ensure that executives retain job security and fair treatment during a merger or acquisition, delineating their rights and entitlements in the process. These provisions serve to clarify an executive’s authority and can have a significant impact on their compensation, in many cases entitling them to severance pay in the event of an M&A transaction. It is crucial for executives to be aware of these provisions and their implications, as they can greatly influence their financial security in connection with M&A deals.

Golden parachute clauses provide financial protection for executives in the event of a merger or acquisition by offering severance packages, such benefits as other compensation, and additional duties that may be assigned. These clauses sometimes serve as a deterrent to hostile takeovers of public companies by increasing the costs associated with an acquisition.

The board of directors or executive committees may also have similar provisions in their executive agreements, which can include clauses to pay executive severance or other benefits in case of termination, change in control, or an executive’s death, as well as other duties as may be agreed upon.

Retention Bonuses and Incentives

Retention bonuses and incentives play a crucial role in motivating executives to remain with the company during and after an M&A transaction, ensuring stability and continuity. To keep the executive committed, these bonuses are often contingent upon the successful fulfillment of predetermined performance objectives and may be subject to claw back provisions.

When negotiating a sign-on bonus, executives should weigh the benefits of a higher executive’s base salary against the potential risks associated with the new company’s long-term sustainability.

Other Key Contract Terms for Senior Executives in M&A Scenarios

In M&A scenarios, senior executives should pay close attention to key contract terms that can impact their employment, such as role and responsibilities, employment duration and termination, and compensation adjustments. Ensuring that these terms are well-defined and negotiated can help protect the executive’s interests and position them for success during and after an M&A deal.

Role and Responsibilities

Clearly defining an executive’s job duties while the executive remains employed with the company before and after an M&A deal is essential for a smooth transition and minimizing potential conflicts. Some key considerations for defining an executive’s role include officer and board positions, reporting structures, expected responsibilities, and such other duties as may be required by the company. The company should also permit the executive to assume outside board and advisory positions that do not create a conflict of interest. In this context, the executive represents the interests of the company while navigating the complexities of the M&A transaction.

By establishing clear expectations, both the executive and the company can better navigate the challenges and opportunities that arise during the deal.

Employment Duration and Termination

Employment duration and termination clauses in an executive’s employment contract should be carefully negotiated to protect the executive’s interests during a merger or acquisition. A fixed term contract with mutual early termination clauses can help ensure that both the executive and the company are protected in the event of unforeseen circumstances, such as when a company terminates an executive’s employment. When considering employment, it is crucial to establish clear terms and conditions.

Additionally, with-cause termination clauses should be based on matters within the purview of the offending party, allowing for a fair and equitable resolution in case of disputes.

Compensation and Benefits Adjustments

Compensation and employee benefits adjustments may be necessary in connection with mergers and acquisitions and should be negotiated to ensure fair treatment and continued motivation. Factors to consider when assessing the value of severance plans and other benefits triggered on the executive’s termination include the size of the company, the number of employees, and prevailing market terms.

By carefully evaluating these factors, executives can better navigate the negotiation process and secure favorable terms in their employment agreements.

Executive employees are wise to lock up severance or other benefits as part of their employment agreements.

M&A Legal Considerations in Executive Employment Agreements

In addition to the specific terms of an employment agreement, there are several legal considerations that executives should be aware of during M&A scenarios, including cause and good reason provisions, non-compete and confidentiality clauses, tax implications, and applicable law. Understanding these legal aspects can help executives protect their interests and navigate potential challenges during the negotiation process.

Cause and Good Reason

Cause and good reason clauses play a critical role in protecting an executive’s interests during a merger or acquisition. These clauses should be clearly defined in the agreement, outlining specific and narrow reasons why the company can terminate the executive’s employment. A “without cause” termination typically occurs if the company terminates executive’s employment on written notice for reasons not having to do with “bad acts” of the executive (such as the executive’s dishonesty or similar conduct), or which are otherwise unrelated a failure to perform the executive’s duties. A “good reason” termination occurs if the executive terminates their employment with the company due to things like loss of job responsibilities, decreased pay, or being required by the company to move to a different geographic location. Optimally, the agreement should not include subjective reasons allowing the company to terminate the executive’s employment without cause.

By having well-defined cause and good reason provisions, the executive better ensures their job is protected and that they will be adequately compensated on termination of executive’s employment without cause or for good reason.

Non-Compete and Confidentiality Clauses

Non-compete, confidentiality and trade secrets clauses are important provisions in any executive employment agreement that protect the company’s interests while not hindering the executive’s career growth or future opportunities. These clauses typically restrict an executive from engaging in competition with the employer or divulging confidential information.

When negotiating these provisions, executives should carefully consider the scope and duration of the restrictions to ensure that they are reasonable and are only as broad as the maximum extent permitted by law. If negotiated incorrectly, these provisions can impede the right of the executive to obtain other employment.

Tax implications are critical for companies and executives alike in employment agreements.

Tax Implications

Tax implications of M&A deals can impact an executive employment agreement, as they may affect the tax treatment related to sale provisions, golden parachute clauses, and other compensation arrangements. Executives should be aware of these implications, including potential taxes imposed, and work with their legal representatives to ensure fair tax treatment.

By understanding the tax consequences of their employment agreements, executives can better protect their interests and maximize their financial benefits in M&A scenarios. Where equity incentive compensation that is subject to vesting based on the performance of an executive’s obligations, the executive should obtain tax counsel as the filing of what is referred to as an “83(b) election” may be required. In these instances, the failure to file an 83(b) election may result in the executive potentially violating applicable law.

Strategies to Obtain the Right Employment Agreement

To successfully navigate M&A employment agreement negotiations, executives should utilize a variety of strategies, including understanding leverage points, collaborating with legal counsel, and maintaining flexibility and adaptability.

By using these strategies, executives can better position themselves for success and ensure their interests are protected during the negotiation process. It is unlikely in most cases that companies will renegotiate the employment contract after it has been signed, and therefore an executive’s maximum leverage exists prior to entering into the agreement.

Understanding Leverage Points; Flexibility and Adaptability

Understanding leverage points in negotiations can help executives secure favorable terms in their employment agreements concerning M&A. Additionally, executives should be aware of how negotiating leverage varies throughout the deal cycle, as this knowledge can help them exploit opportunities and achieve better outcomes.

Flexibility and adaptability are crucial during M&A negotiations, as executives must be prepared to adjust their expectations and priorities in response to changing circumstances. This may involve being open to negotiation, willingness to make concessions, and able to modify the agreement as necessary.

By maintaining flexibility and adaptability, an executive can better navigate the challenges and opportunities that arise during M&A negotiations.

Conclusion

In conclusion, navigating M&A employment agreement negotiations can be a complex and challenging process, but with the right strategies and an understanding of key issues, executives can successfully protect their interests and secure favorable terms for themselves. By focusing on the complexities of M&A employment agreements, key contract terms, legal considerations, and employing effective negotiation strategies, executives can position themselves for success during and after a merger or acquisition.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do you get severance as part of an M&A deal?

Only if the employee is entitled to such rights in their executive employment agreement.

What are the key complexities associated with M&A in an executive employment agreement?

An executive employment agreement involves several complexities associated with M&A, such as company sale related provisions, golden parachute clauses, and retention bonuses, making them an important consideration for the organization and executives.

These complexities can have a significant impact on the financial and legal obligations of executive’s and companies alike. These should be carefully considered when preparing the employment contract. It is important to ensure that the agreement is tailored to the specific needs of the organization and its executives.

How can understanding leverage points help executives in employment agreement negotiations?

Understanding leverage points can empower executives to strategically identify opportunities and reach more advantageous outcomes in M&A employment agreement negotiations.

By understanding the key points of leverage, executives can better understand the dynamics of the negotiation process and use them to their advantage.

Why is it important to collaborate with legal counsel during negotiations of an executive employment agreement?

Collaborating with legal counsel during M&A employment agreement negotiations is important to ensure that executives are well-informed and protected and will normally result in a more successful outcome for the executive.

Having the right legal counsel can help executives understand the implications of their employment agreement and ensure that their interests are protected. This can help result in the employment agreement being fair and beneficial to both parties.

It is also important for executives to examine employment agreements for any long-term implications or restrictions that may be imposed on them that could affect their future career opportunities.

Denver Business Journal - Leadership Trust

Top Business Lawyer 2020 by Superpages

Barrister's Best 2019 Patrick Linden Best Private Equity Lawyer

Barrister's Best 2018 Pat Linden

Top Rated Super Lawyers 2021

Barrister's Best 2021 Pat Linden

Barrister's Best Pat Linden

Top Rated Super Lawyers 2022

Top Rated Super Lawyers 2023

10 Key Components Of Successfully Selling Your Business

Download Our Free Guide

10 Key Components Of Successfully
Selling Your Business

Download Now